• Contact
  • Connexion

The Better Way to Fix Foreign Aid

"Time for it to die.” That verdict on USAID, by Department of Government Efficiency head Elon Musk, set off shockwaves in the aid industry and beyond.

The Better Way to Fix Foreign Aid

(Photo : U.S. Army Southern European Task Force, Africa CC https://www.flickr.com/photos/usarmyafrica/3658842161)

"Time for it to die.” That verdict on USAID, by Department of Government Efficiency head Elon Musk, set off shockwaves in the aid industry and beyond. Whether motivated by revenge (95% of campaign contributions by USAID personnel went to Democrats) or other impulses, the Trump Administration is terminating close to nine out of ten USAID programs. The wrecking-ball is aimed at everything from civil society to education, health, infrastructure, reproductive rights, and more. Cuts to humanitarian relief and public health are particularly worrying ; for example, the U.S. reportedly plans to de-fund the global vaccine alliance Gavi that has saved millions of lives and is freezing or terminating support for a range of vital U.N. bodies.

Yet it is aid under the banner of “development” that has shown mixed and often disappointing results, and correctly deserves scrutiny. Outcomes of decades of aid to poorer countries include enfeebled public services, lackluster investment, rising inequality, and growing poverty. Such setbacks have often stemmed from “conditionalities”—which demand austerity, privatization, and trade liberalization—that the World Bank and IMF set from atop the aid system in Washington, D.C.

There is also a common misunderstanding about how much is spent on aid and where it goes. Aid accounts for about a modest 1% of the U.S. federal budget. And rather than disappearing down “ratholes” overseas, most is paid out within the U.S. itself, mainly to American contractors that account for the majority of USAID spending. Such “tying” of aid is one among multiple ways donor countries help themselves.

It is against this backdrop that U.S. foreign aid is losing its monopolies. In the 21 years up to 2022, China paid out roughly $68 billion per year (mainly in loans) in aid-like investments, outspending the U.S. in roughly that period by about 75%. Even after adjusting for the fact that the U.S. has considerable influence (including de facto veto power) in the World Bank and IMF, and thereby has sway over all other Western donors, there are reasons to see China as a source of serious aid competition. Chinese aid is often driven by commercial ends (as in the case of Western donors, whose aid is tending to resemble that of China) and doesn’t come with conditions on political change or market liberalization. New donors such as India, Turkey, and Brazil are also offering South-to-South aid on non-patronizing terms like those of China.

Adding to recipient resentments are concerns about “spillovers.” The U.N. has begun monitoring them—that is, how the activities of some countries can hinder progress toward achieving the U.N.’s landmark Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that aim to ensure that all people enjoy health, justice, and prosperity. The U.S. generates many negative spillovers and its aid does not redress them. Unsurprisingly, the Trump Administration “rejects and denounces” the SDGs.

One of the main Western spillovers is wealth drain from poorer to richer places. One 2021 study put the figure at $62 trillion since 1960, and noted that it has been 14 times larger than Western aid in recent years. Some of these flows are fairly earned as a result of square dealing in trade, technologies, and investments. But a lot of them consist of rents—value extracted through unfair political-juridical advantage.

The rentier is at the heart of today’s perverse system. The U.S. economist Lawrence Summers, a longtime cheerleader of free trade and globalization, recently acknowledged the monies draining from poorer places. “Millions in, billions out,” he and co-author N.K. Singh wrote.

Such losses can’t be directly put at the aid system’s doorstep. But doctrines to shrink-the-state and cut taxes have limited revenue collection, thus hindering self-reliance. Further, the IMF’s approach has pushed poor countries to divert capital available for domestic investment and public services into international currency reserves ; these effectively become low-interest loans, mainly to the U.S.

A few exceptional donors, such as Norway, recognize spillovers such as tax evasion and illicit financial flows, which harm all countries but hit poor ones disproportionately. Those donors and policy activists call for policy changes to stop them, and to help poorer countries exit from aid, chiefly by mobilizing domestic revenues.

Angus Deacon, a professor at Princeton and winner of the Nobel Prize in economics, sees too many downsides in conventional aid. In his book, Economics in America, he urges us instead “to agitate for our own governments to stop doing the things that make it harder for poor countries to stop being poor.”

In my view, this means : stop those spillovers and harmful aid conditionalities. And rather than kill off aid agencies, like the Trump Administration seems intent on, we could, as the renowned economist John Maynard Keynes advocated in 1936, start with the euthanasia of the rentier.


Les opinions exprimées et les arguments avancés dans cet article demeurent l'entière responsabilité de l'auteur-e et ne reflètent pas nécessairement ceux du CETRI.

Lire aussi ...

Conférence tricontinentale : nommer le monde pour le transformer, des récits et des luttes

12 octobre 2026

À l’occasion de son cinquantième anniversaire, le CETRI a organisé une journée de réflexion le 17 septembre 2026 pour explorer l’évolution des rapports Nord-Sud au cours des dernières décennies. Cet événement, « Du tiers-monde au Sud global : 50 ans de luttes anticoloniales », a donné la parole (…)

Du tiers-monde au Sud global : quels changements dans les relations Nord-Sud ?

12 octobre 2026

Enregistrement audio de la première table ronde qui s’est tenue lors du 50e anniversaire du CETRI, le 17 septembre 2026, afin d’explorer l’évolution des rapports Nord-Sud au cours des dernières décennies. Cette table ronde animée par François Polet (CETRI) a réuni trois intellectuel·les (…)

Les défis de la solidarité internationale

12 octobre 2026

Enregistrement audio de la deuxième table ronde qui s’est tenue lors du 50e anniversaire du CETRI, le 17 septembre 2026, en vue d’analyser les défis de la solidarité internationale, dans les domaines des droits humains, de la migration et de la régulation des échanges commerciaux. Une table (…)

Viser le surtourisme, c’est se tromper de cible

5 octobre 2026

Le « surtourisme » est devenu le mot-clé des débats sur les « excès » du voyage. Mais en focalisant les critiques sur les foules et les destinations saturées, ne passe-t-on pas à côté du véritable enjeu ? Pour Bernard Duterme (CETRI), auteur de La touristification du monde (Paris, Syllepse, (…)

Trump’s “Agreements on Reciprocal Trade” (ARTs) Threaten Equitable Access to the Internet in Developing Countries

22 septembre 2026

Around the world, one in every three people has no reliable access to the internet. Unequal access to the internet creates digital divides that can limit civic participation, undermine access to education and healthcare, and deepen inequality. It can also reduce innovation, industrial growth, (…)

Nuevo colonialismo y crisis en las resistencias

14 septembre 2026

Cuando la fuerza armada permite a una potencia gobernar otros territorios y naciones, de forma directa o indirecta, y hacerse con el control de los principales recursos, despojando pueblos enteros de sus riquezas, estamos ante una relación colonial profundamente asimétrica que podemos calificar (…)

Nicaragua : l’ultime raidissement du régime ?

1er septembre 2026

Dans cette « carte blanche » publiée par Le Soir, Bernard Duterme (CETRI), auteur de Toujours sandiniste, le Nicaragua ? (Bruxelles, Couleur Livres) et de Amérique latine : les nouveaux conflits (Paris, Syllepse), tente de décrypter le nouveau verrouillage dictatorial du régime de Daniel Ortega (…)

Comment les États-Unis apposent une « logique transactionnelle » à l’aide sanitaire en Afrique

25 août 2026

Des accords bilatéraux avec une vingtaine de pays africains ont déjà été signés, renforçant l’influence américaine dans la région. Un article de Nathan Scheirlinckx (La Libre Belgique) provenant d’un entretien avec Aurélie Leroy (CETRI). Depuis que Donald Trump est revenu à la Maison-Blanche, (…)

Trade Liberalisation Never Lifted All Boat

11 août 2026

President Trump has blamed trade liberalisation advocated by globalists for US deindustrialisation. Instead, his own weaponisation of economic policies, instruments and institutions purport to ‘make America great again’ (MAGA). Trump 1.0 claimed to do so by ‘reshoring’ industries that had (…)

US knows UAE fueling war in Sudan but $1.4 trillion is getting in the way

9 juillet 2026

The Emirates promised Trump a huge investment, which appears to be playing a role in Washington’s unwillingness to intervene in their arm sales to RSF. Massad Boulos, the Trump Administration’s top adviser for Africa and point man on Sudan, recently spoke before the United Nations Security (…)

Trump II et les guerres au Moyen-Orient : crise de l’ordre international et fragmentation du Sud global

6 juillet 2026

Entretien avec Gilbert Achcar mené par Laurent Delcourt (CETRI) Depuis la fin de la Guerre froide, les États-Unis façonnent le Moyen-Orient par des interventions militaires et un alignement avec Israël. La séquence Trump–Biden–Trump a renforcé la dynamique, à Gaza comme en Iran. Prévalent (…)

The Most Racist World Cup In History

16 juin 2026

The football World Cup starts this Thursday and the US regime has already guaranteed that it will be the most racist in history. FIFA-appointed Somalian referee Omar Artan, voted the best referee in Africa last year and travelling on a diplomatic passport, was denied entry to the USwhen he (…)