• Contact
  • Connexion

Industrial Policy, East or West, for Development or War ?

Developing countries wanting to pursue industrial policy were severely reprimanded by advocates of the ‘neoliberal’ Washington Consensus. Now, it is being deployed as a weapon in the new Cold War.

Industrial Policy, East or West, for Development or War ?

(Photo : Bangladesh, Asian Development Bank CC https://www.flickr.com/photos/asiandevelopmentbank/8424936977)

Developing countries wanting to pursue industrial policy were severely reprimanded by advocates of the ‘neoliberal’ Washington Consensus. Now, it is being deployed as a weapon in the new Cold War.

Industrial policy vs colonialism

Industrial policy is often seen as pioneered by Friedrich List. But List was inspired by George Washington’s first Treasury Secretary, Alexander Hamilton. He advocated promoting manufacturing as the Industrial Revolution was beginning in England.

For List, post-colonial national development required tariffs. Despite a title deceptively similar to his earlier Principles of the Natural Economy, List’s Principles of the National Economy was quite different, clearly inspired by Hamilton.

The Meiji Restoration started in 1868, after a quarter millennium of Tokugawa shogunate military rule. Meiji emperor rule was no mere palace coup but involved industrial policy to catch up with the already industrialising West.

Meanwhile, public intellectuals like Dadabhai Naoroji and Sayyid Jamaluddin al-Afghani rejected Western imperialism. They criticised how parts of the global South were being transformed – and ruined – by Western imperialism.

Half a century later, Harvard’s Josef Schumpeter rejected the idea that capitalism had become imperialistic. The Austrian economist insisted imperialism was a pre-capitalist atavism that capitalism’s ascendance would wipe out.

Weaponising industrial policy

Today’s geopolitics has seen a renewed Western interest in industrial policy as a weapon in the new Cold War. US President Joe Biden’s National Security Adviser, Jake Sullivan, is widely credited with articulating its use as an economic weapon.

This contrasts significantly with longstanding interest in industrial policy in the global South over several decades. For many, industrial policy has long been associated with post-colonial development efforts.

Meanwhile, strong stagnation tendencies in the West after the 2008 global financial crisis underscored the failure of purported neoliberalism. Advocacy of transformative, including green industrial policies by Mariana Mazzucato and others in Europe, was well received by desperate governments keen to resume growth.

Developmental, industrial policy

However, in developing countries, there has long been interest in developmental industrial policy. Neoliberal economists and the many influential financial institutions they control have long frowned upon this.

Alfred Marshall, Petrus Johannes Verdoorn, Nicholas Kaldor and others urged Europe to industrialise. Selective industrial policy has been even more controversial, with the government favouring some manufacturing activities over others, e.g., due to increasing returns to scale.

Typically facing resource, including fiscal constraints, developing countries have had little choice but to be selective. However, with such powers associated with governments, there was understandable concern about the potential for abuse, arbitrariness and error.

Instead, the market was supposed to decide in the best interests of society without recognising its own inherent biases and ‘failures’, especially in highly unequal post-colonial societies. Neoliberal economists were quick to caricature industrial policy with dismissive metaphors (e.g., picking winners) rather than rigorous analysis.

Asian miracles ?

The East Asian Miracle was simplistically caricatured due to the abandonment of import-substituting industrialisation in favour of export-orientation. A more nuanced alternative narrative of ‘effective protection conditional on export promotion’ in Northeast Asia was thus ignored.

Industrial policy is much more than trade policy, involving a range of policy instruments. Recognising the variegated aspects, dimensions and tools of industrial policy is essential. Besides investment, finance, and technology, human resource development is also significant.

For instance, the Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) were an important initiative to support its industry. However, with India’s gradual neglect of industrial policy, IITs have probably contributed more to the development of US hi-tech.

Evaluating industrial policy

For years, economists working on India have criticised industrial policy, usually referring to the Nehruvian experience. But rushing to such a conclusion solely referencing that experience requires cherry-picking evidence.

India’s pharmaceutical policy has been crucial to the health and well-being of its population. Affordable, often generic medicines in India have been central to its improved public health outcomes. However, unlike Western pharmaceutical transnational corporations, Indian companies have not been accused of price-gouging.

Bangladesh has since utilised its special dispensation as a least developed country (LDC) to export affordable generic medicines to many other poor countries. However, the West blocked the Indian-South African initiative to suspend patent royalties to address the COVID-19 pandemic for its duration.

Effectively, the West was reneging on its 2001 agreement to the Public Health Exception to Trade-Related Industrial Property Rights (TRIPS). This compromise was needed to restart WTO processes after the African walkout from the 1999 Seattle World Trade Organization (WTO) ministerial meeting.

If not for India and Bangladesh, the costs of medicines would have been much higher, and there would be more ill health in the world today. Defining industrial policy success solely in terms of the financial profitability of investments ignores such gains.

It is, therefore, crucial to build coalitions to create the conditions for sustained and appropriate but adaptive industrial policies. These are needed to accelerate growth and structural transformation to achieve sustainable development in the face of stagnation and regression in much of the world, especially the global South.


Les opinions exprimées et les arguments avancés dans cet article demeurent l'entière responsabilité de l'auteur-e et ne reflètent pas nécessairement ceux du CETRI.

Lire aussi ...

Guerra híbrida : La triple alianza y el modelo extractivista chileno

3 novembre 2026

La Ley Orgánica de Constitucional de Concesiones Mineras (LOCCM, 1982) otorgó una cobertura jurídica al extractivismo cuya práctica fue la política oficial del Estado de Chile. En las décadas de 1980 y 1990, el país exportaba una cantidad equilibrada de cátodos refinados de alta pureza. Sin (…)

Guatemala : espoirs déçus, partie remise ?

30 octobre 2026

Élu président en 2023 sur une promesse de rupture avec la corruption, Bernardo Arévalo a suscité un immense espoir. Trois ans plus tard, la désillusion domine. Entre institutions capturées, renoncements présidentiels et inégalités persistantes, le Guatemala reste prisonnier de ses vieux rapports (…)

Pour changer le monde, il faut d’abord l’analyser et le comprendre

29 octobre 2026

Le monde d’aujourd’hui va mal, très mal, et cela pourrait être pire demain : il est menacé par des crises, plus dangereuses les unes que les autres, et son avenir (celui de l’humanité et celui de la planète où elle habite) court un réel danger. Voyons quelles sont ces crises, quelles sont leurs (…)

State Sovereignty, People’s Sovereignty : Perspectives from Indonesia

20 octobre 2026

In a context marked by geopolitical upheavals and growing challenges to the world order, Rachmi Hertanti examines the contradictions inherent in the sovereignty driven projects promoted by many states in the Global South. Drawing on the Indonesian experience and on debates within popular (…)

La Belgique face à la facture cachée de l’arbitrage investisseur-État

19 octobre 2026

Alors que le Gouvernement fédéral peine à trouver 10 milliards d’euros pour boucler le budget, la Belgique pourrait être contrainte par des tribunaux d’arbitrage privés de verser des milliards d’euros de dédommagement à des oligarques russes et à des investisseurs étrangers. Les tribunaux (…)

Conférence tricontinentale : nommer le monde pour le transformer, des récits et des luttes

12 octobre 2026

À l’occasion de son cinquantième anniversaire, le CETRI a organisé une journée de réflexion le 17 septembre 2026 pour explorer l’évolution des rapports Nord-Sud au cours des dernières décennies. Cet événement, « Du tiers-monde au Sud global : 50 ans de luttes anticoloniales », a donné la parole (…)

Du tiers-monde au Sud global : quels changements dans les relations Nord-Sud ?

12 octobre 2026

Enregistrement audio de la première table ronde qui s’est tenue lors du 50e anniversaire du CETRI, le 17 septembre 2026, afin d’explorer l’évolution des rapports Nord-Sud au cours des dernières décennies. Cette table ronde animée par François Polet (CETRI) a réuni trois intellectuel·les (…)

Les défis de la solidarité internationale

12 octobre 2026

Enregistrement audio de la deuxième table ronde qui s’est tenue lors du 50e anniversaire du CETRI, le 17 septembre 2026, en vue d’analyser les défis de la solidarité internationale, dans les domaines des droits humains, de la migration et de la régulation des échanges commerciaux. Une table (…)

Souveraineté des États, souveraineté des peuples : regards depuis l’Indonésie

8 octobre 2026

Dans un contexte de bouleversements géopolitiques et de remise en cause de l’ordre mondial, Rachmi Hertanti analyse les contradictions des projets souverainistes portés par de nombreux États du Sud global. À partir de l’expérience indonésienne et des débats menés au sein des mouvements (…)

Viser le surtourisme, c’est se tromper de cible

5 octobre 2026

Le « surtourisme » est devenu le mot-clé des débats sur les « excès » du voyage. Mais en focalisant les critiques sur les foules et les destinations saturées, ne passe-t-on pas à côté du véritable enjeu ? Pour Bernard Duterme (CETRI), auteur de La touristification du monde (Paris, Syllepse, (…)

Trump’s “Agreements on Reciprocal Trade” (ARTs) Threaten Equitable Access to the Internet in Developing Countries

22 septembre 2026

Around the world, one in every three people has no reliable access to the internet. Unequal access to the internet creates digital divides that can limit civic participation, undermine access to education and healthcare, and deepen inequality. It can also reduce innovation, industrial growth, (…)

International Trade Theory Not Developmental

14 septembre 2026

Most free trade advocates falsely claim that comparative advantage ensures developmental gains from trade liberalisation. Mainstream trade theory does not promise that partial trade liberalisation guarantees optimal international specialisation. Specialisation ? Developing countries are (…)